In recent days, social networks have been buzzing with the news that Pham Thoai donated more than 16 billion VND to babyap to treat leukemia.
Pham Thoai's livestream attracted hundreds of thousands of views, with the appearance of Ms. Hoa (Mother ofap) and related characters.
After that, this TikToker published all the information on statements, revenue and expenditure, and payment invoices during the process of Ms. Hoa taking her child for treatment.
Pham Thoai affirmed that the money that benefactors sent into his account was all used to pay for the treatment of baby award, "not used for any other purpose".
The incident continues to be a hot topic on social networks, as the online community continues to question the 3 personal accounts Ms. Hoa used to receive support.
In the posts, the audience also mentioned Hoai Linh, Thuy Tien and many artists who were involved in scandals related to charity.
Remember in 2021, the incident of artist Hoai Linh being slow to disburse 14 billion VND in charity money once caused public outrage. This incident seriously affected Hoai Linh's career afterwards.
Meanwhile, the audience reminded Thuy Tien of the old story, from the female singer holding "money" to the flooded areas to give to the people, not having a professional disbursement process, which once made the audience unhappy.
According to expert Le Ngoc Son, charitable donations often have to go through a reputable charity fund with a detailed, specific, and clear disbursement plan. Calling for charity through personal accounts can easily cause controversy.
Although she has made statements and concluded from the authorities, Thuy Tien is still often bothered by offensive comments.
The female singer once affirmed that the investigation results of the Ministry of Public Security concluded that she "did not appropriate charity money contributed and supported by the people to provide relief to the people of the Central region affected by natural disasters and floods in 2020" and hoped the audience would stop insulting her. But the audience still repeated and thought that they could not raise money and then do emotional charity.
Media expert Nguyen Ngoc Long expressed his views on Pham Thoai's noise: "You are only right when people believe you are right, but if doubts arise, you are always wrong. There are many good examples. Even if we finally have all the evidence and the police's conclusion, trust is something that can never be taken back by unknown documents".
Mr. Nguyen Ngoc Long said that Pham Thoai was not close and clearly understood the information from Ms. Hoa, "make things more complicated and have more false information".
Charity is a valuable activity, but it has never been simple and easy. Individuals and organizations that receive donations and spending help people need to strictly control their finances, methodically, and operate legally.
If there is only enthusiasm, the simple thought that when you reach the place to hand over, it will be a big risk for both the calling person and the contributor.
