Plagiarized PhDs and "super-fast" PhDs are also a waste

Lê Thanh Phong |

Hue University has not yet concluded the case of the doctoral thesis accused of plagiarism, and the case of the "super-fast" doctoral thesis has not yet been answered.

On July 13, 2024, Lao Dong Newspaper published an article "Clarifying accusations of "super-speed" PhDs and PhD plagiarism is the responsibility of the Ministry of Education and Training", in which it stated a very clear point of view, bringing to light doctoral theses accused of plagiarism and "super-speed", tracing to the end the process of studying a master's or doctoral program, clarifying the responsibilities of the supervisor, the thesis review board and handling them seriously, in accordance with the provisions of the law, only then can scientific research activities be rectified, bringing the works back to reality.

But up to now, both the accusations of plagiarized doctoral theses and "super-fast" doctoral theses have not yet had conclusions from responsible agencies.

Regarding the doctoral thesis accused of plagiarism, Hue University has postponed it twice, but still has not resolved it. The latest extension, on September 17, Hue University said that it had issued a notice on the extension of the complaint settlement. Accordingly, in order to carry out the relevant procedures and conclude the complaint settlement, the Director of Hue University issued a decision to extend the complaint settlement. The extension period is 30 days, starting from September 13, 2024. The deadline has now expired.

Regarding the "super-fast" doctoral thesis case, on June 2, the Ministry of Education and Training issued an urgent document, requesting Hanoi Law University to urgently report and send it to the Ministry by June 26, 2024. Up to now, more than three months have passed, with complete silence.

Because of that silence, at the National Assembly forum on October 9, Chairman of the National Assembly's Economic Committee Vu Hong Thanh expressed his opinion: "In 2024, public opinion will be stirred up by the case of "fake scholars, real degrees" at the highest level of training. However, the state management agency of education has not yet had a satisfactory, public, and transparent handling measure with the public."

The problem of "fake degrees, real degrees" at the highest level of training that Mr. Vu Hong Thanh mentioned is also a concern of the whole society. There have been many accusations about "incubator" PhDs, "super-fast" PhDs, and "plagiarized" PhDs, which have made society skeptical about dishonest, poor quality, and even negative signs of PhD degrees.

I strongly agree with the viewpoint of "properly handling, publicly and transparently with public opinion" of Chairman of the Economic Committee of the National Assembly Vu Hong Thanh, this is the way to rectify the current shortcomings and negative aspects of doctoral training.

The development of the country requires substantial scientific works, talented scientists and a progressive, quality and honest education.

Scientific works and doctoral theses without substance are also a type of waste that needs to be eliminated.

Lê Thanh Phong
TIN LIÊN QUAN

People are upset because the residential road to Tran Hung cemetery is blocked

|

Hanoi - People in Phu Dien ward are upset because the road leading to Tran Hung cemetery is blocked, making it difficult to visit the ancestral tomb.

Hanoi proposes to pilot the removal of notarization and certification for real estate transactions

|

Hanoi is considering piloting the removal of notarization and certification of real estate donation contracts between individuals in the project.

HCMC reports after residents texted Standing Deputy Secretary of the City Party Committee Nguyen Thanh Nghi

|

HCMC - Regarding the reporter's text message to Standing Deputy Secretary of the HCMC Party Committee Nguyen Thanh Nghi, the HCMC People's Committee has just reported the handling results.

The contrasting picture behind PJICO's growth figures

|

Motor vehicle insurance brings a large source of income to PJICO, but also carries high risks because all compensation is borne by the enterprise itself.

Fire in a tourist electric vehicle parking lot in Huong Tich pagoda area, many cars burned down

|

Ha Tinh - At noon on July 8, a major fire broke out at the electric car parking lot in the Huong Tich pagoda tourist area, burning down 9 electric cars and 1 car.

Consider handling organizations and individuals if there are violations in the bidding package proposed by Son Hai Group

|

The Ministry of Finance has just sent a document reporting to the Government on the bid package previously proposed by Son Hai Group.

Toll station devastated after landslide, people holding the scene demand compensation for cultivated land

|

Lao Cai - After many days of landslides, the Sa Pa BOT Toll Station area is still in disarray.

Quá hạn vẫn chưa có kết luận luận án tiến sĩ bị tố đạo văn

PHÚC ĐẠT |

HUẾ - Dù đã quá hạn nhưng Đại học Huế vẫn chưa có kết luận vụ việc luận án tiến sĩ bị tố đạo văn.

Làm việc với người tố cáo luận án tiến sĩ đạo văn

PHÚC ĐẠT |

HUẾ - Không chỉ luận án tiến sĩ, một số công trình nghiên cứu của trưởng phòng nghiên cứu khoa học ở Huế cũng bị tố đạo văn.

Làm rõ tố cáo tiến sĩ "siêu tốc", tiến sĩ đạo văn là trách nhiệm của Bộ Giáo dục và Đào tạo

Lê Thanh Phong |

Gần đây, liên tục xảy ra các vụ tố cáo liên quan đến tiến sĩ "siêu tốc", tiến sĩ đạo văn, thu hút sự quan tâm của giới nghiên cứu và cộng đồng xã hội.