Music Shows “Brother”, “Sister” and the “Disappearance” of the Band

Linh Chi |

Finding members to form a band is one of the purposes of organizing the shows “Brother” and “Sister”, but so far no winning band has been debuted from these shows.

The “disappearance” of winning groups

Programs such as “Sister Who Makes Wave”, “Call Me by Fire”, “Anh trai say hi”… are introduced as places for artists to express themselves and find talented members to form a band after the program. However, up to now, the band consisting of the winning members after this program has “disappeared”, leaving the audience disappointed.

Typically, the Top 7 of “Sister Who Makes Wave 2023” includes: Diva My Linh, Le Quyen, Thu Phuong, Ninh Duong Lan Ngoc, Trang Phap, Diep Lam Anh and Mlee. More than a year has passed since the final night, and these top 7 have never stood on the same stage, let alone released a song together.

The lineup of “Sister Who Makes Wave 2023” also faced rumors of discord among the members, causing many viewers to joke that the newly formed group had disbanded.

A program that received a lot of attention was “Anh trai say hi” with the Top 5 “Anh trai Best Five” including: HIEUTHUHAI, Quang Anh Rhyder, Quang Hung MasterD, Duc Phuc and Issac. The 5 “brothers” announced to form the music group of “Anh trai say hi” were commented by the audience to have completely different colors, some of whom had never been in the same group during the time participating in “Anh trai say hi”.

Several months have passed and 4 "Anh trai say hi" concerts have taken place from Ho Chi Minh City to Hanoi, but "Anh trai Best Five" still doesn't have a song together.

When talking about the plan of "Best Five Brother", HIEUTHUHAI just smiled at the concert, while Duc Phuc hinted: "There will definitely be a gift to thank the audience, but how fast or slow it will be depends on HIEUTHUHAI, Quang Anh Rhyder and Quang Hung MasterD".

The fact that “Best Five Brothers” have not been released together has also disappointed many audiences who spent a lot of money to vote for the 5 “brothers”. However, names like HIEUTHUHAI, Quang Anh RHYDER, Quang Hung Master D... are currently the most sought-after young artists at the moment. Therefore, it is easy to see that they have not had time to release a song together.

Another show, “Call Me by Fire,” has also received a lot of attention. After the “Almighty Family” was announced with 17 members, they have yet to perform on stage together despite having participated in two grand concerts. The audience voting for their favorite member has created a “paradox” in music shows, when famous artists tend to prioritize their personal schedules over the group.

When actors cross over into singers

Another thing that caught the audience’s attention was that after the end of the “brother, sister” shows, many actors crossed over to the singing industry and debuted as members of music groups. Ninh Duong Lan Ngoc was the first actress to “lead the way” when she debuted the music group LUNAS with singers from the “Sister” show such as: Trang Phap, Khong Tu Quynh, Huyen Baby and Diep Lam Anh.

Although highly appreciated for their visuals, LUNAS songs such as “Hoa xuong cactus” and “Moonlight” still cause controversy. In particular, Ninh Duong Lan Ngoc once caused controversy for her weak and out of place singing voice compared to the other 4 members.

Recently, other actors Dieu Nhi and Hau Hoang also surprised everyone when they teamed up with Duong Hoang Yen to form the music group XYNTRA. In XYNTRA, Duong Hoang Yen is a talented singer, however, the female singer gave the spotlight to her two colleagues by taking on the role of rapper.

Or the B.O.F band including: BB Tran, Bui Cong Nam, ST. Son Thach, Kay Tran and Jun Pham after "Call Me by Fire". Originally a comedian, BB Tran also caused skepticism when becoming a member of a band. In the MV "Tet dinh noc" - a newly released product of the B.O.F band, BB Tran did not really stand out and was somewhat overshadowed compared to the other 4 members who were all singers. Sharing with Lao Dong, BB Tran admitted that at first he was hesitant when accepting to join the B.O.F band because he did not know in what capacity he would participate.

“After that, I thought I had joined “Call Me by Fire” for nearly a year to learn a lot from the “talents” and the program’s crew. When the program ended, why not take advantage of those things, so I decided to apply what I had learned to join this band. Currently, I will continue to learn from the members so that in the coming time, I can experience more new things” - BB Tran said.

The Vietnamese showbiz market is not favorable for developing a music group model. To make an impression and go the long way, music groups coming out of these programs need to be different, and have a well-crafted music product.

Linh Chi
TIN LIÊN QUAN

Blackpink ranked Top 1 girl group reputation in early 2025

|

Blackpink started 2025 with the Top 1 position on the Kpop girl group reputation chart.

The group would hardly succeed without HIEUTHUHAI and Soobin Hoang Son?

|

HIEUTHUHAI and Soobin Hoang Son continue to work individually despite having high rankings in 2 Brother shows.

Anh Tu Atus's wife formed a music group with 2 "Sisters", will it make a difference?

|

The "Sister" cast suddenly announced the project to launch a new girl group consisting of 3 members: Dieu Nhi, Duong Hoang Yen, Hau Hoang.

40% of meat in Hanoi is not strictly controlled

|

The leaders of the Hanoi Department of Agriculture and Environment acknowledged that the amount of meat imported from localities for consumption in the city has not been strictly controlled.

Da Nang stops all paragliding activities in Son Tra mountain area

|

The Management Board of Son Tra Peninsula and Da Nang tourist beaches said that it has stopped all paragliding activities on Son Tra peninsula since July 9.

Dismantling a series of "tiger cages" after the fire that killed 8 people at Doc Lap residence

|

HCMC - After the tragic fire, many households in Doc Lap residence have proactively hired workers to dismantle the expansion items, encroaching on the corridor and balcony.

laughing balls are still hidden in a bar in Ho Chi Minh City, operating vigorously at midnight

|

HCMC - Under the shady lights and the music, laughter is hidden in new covers, bustling at midnight, just for customers to " want fun, I have it".

Cash flow enters strongly, stocks aim for 1,500 points

|

The Vietnamese stock market is having an impressive increase with the return of foreign investor capital.

Blackpink ranked Top 1 girl group reputation in early 2025

DƯƠNG HƯƠNG |

Blackpink started 2025 with the Top 1 position on the Kpop girl group reputation chart.

The group would hardly succeed without HIEUTHUHAI and Soobin Hoang Son?

Huyền Chi |

HIEUTHUHAI and Soobin Hoang Son continue to work individually despite having high rankings in 2 Brother shows.

Anh Tu Atus's wife formed a music group with 2 "Sisters", will it make a difference?

Huyền Chi |

The "Sister" cast suddenly announced the project to launch a new girl group consisting of 3 members: Dieu Nhi, Duong Hoang Yen, Hau Hoang.