In a recent concert in Shenyang (China), Nicholas Tse said 3 times "happy birthday" on stage, right on the day his current girlfriend, singer Faye Wong, turned 57.
In particular, when seeing a fan banner with the content: "Anh Phong, please replace me to wish Ms. Phi a happy birthday", Ta Dinh Phong laughed and sent wishes.
Although not named specifically, the whole social network understands that he sent wishes from afar to his girlfriend Vuong Phi - who did not appear at the concert.
Also on that day, 2,000 km from Shenyang, Truong Ba Chi - Ta Dinh Phong's ex-wife - posted a daily video on social networks. In the video, she was bare-faced, her voice somewhat worried, saying that one of the children was uncomfortable, and had previously fainted. Therefore, she put aside her work to personally pick up and drop off and take care of her children.
On one side was the "happy birthday" sound rang out 3 times under the stage in front of tens of thousands of spectators, on the other side was the image of a mother worried about her child's health condition.
This contrast immediately caused discussion, causing the issue of Ta Dinh Phong's responsibility as a father to once again create controversy.
Previously, in early August, Ta Dinh Phong and Truong Ba Chi's eldest son Lucas (Ta Chan Hien) celebrated his 19th birthday.
Cecilia Cheung posted a happy video with the warm scenery of the two mothers and daughters. In the video, Lucas leaned close to his mother's ear and gently said: "I want to hug you, because I love you". In particular, the actress placed a birthday cake shaped like a musical instrument according to her son's musical preferences - on the cake there are a large drum, guitar and musical notes.
Meanwhile, Nicholas Tse remained completely silent on social networks, without public birthday wishes for his son, and without posting old photos or memories.
His latest post is still content promoting the culinary program "A Feast of the Gods 2". Previously, there were announcements of preparations for the "Evolution" concert at Shenyang Olympic Stadium.
In 2025, when Lucas celebrated his 18th birthday, Nicholas Tse's personal page was also completely silent. His 18th birthday marked a milestone of maturity, he did not publicly appear; even his son's 19th birthday, he did not take any action.
Some fans explained that Ta Dinh Phong does not like to put family relationships on social networks, so not publicly congratulating does not mean that the two father and son do not contact privately.
Netizens mentioned that in 2025, the two fathers and sons went to Dubai together to celebrate their early birthday, Ta Dinh Phong also brought his 2 sons to see his concert and dedicated top positions to his children.
However, the public still believes that the act of "expressing affection on special occasions in front of the public" is necessary.
Another detail that also attracted attention was that not long ago, Dau Tinh Dong - Vuong Phi's daughter organized a personal concert. Flower baskets sent by friends in the industry packed an area, in which Ta Dinh Phong's flower basket was particularly prominent.
On the card, there is only a short greeting: "Good show", the sender does not fully write the name "Ta Dinh Phong" but simply signs "Dinh Phong". People in the industry all understand this way of addressing: only between family members or extremely close people do not need to write their full name.
With Vuong Phi's daughter, he used a nickname; with his biological son, he did not even leave a public wish, and his social media account was so silent that it was unbelievable.
One is a girlfriend who has been with him for many years, and the other is a biological son with shared bloodline. The way Nicholas Tse expressed his feelings and behaved on their birthday caused storms.
