Solve legal problems of real estate projects first, consider taxes later

LÊ THANH PHONG |

There have been many heated arguments regarding the Ministry of Construction’s proposal to impose a progressive tax on individuals who own multiple houses and lands. Most believe that now is not the right time to apply it.

Because the real estate market is frozen, causing many consequences for the economy, if we consider applying progressive taxation, it will be like a blow to the real estate market that is struggling to get up after being "knocked out". Maybe, the market will be negatively affected, continuing to freeze more severely.

Reviving the real estate market is more necessary at this time, not only for the "life" of real estate businesses, but also for many related industries that have the opportunity to make a living, creating jobs for tens of thousands of workers. Not to mention, the activities of the real estate market will create a large source of revenue for the budget, if real estate decreases, the budget will shrink significantly. Typically, in Ho Chi Minh City, land use revenue in 2019 was 14,600 billion VND, in 2022 it was about 9,960 billion VND and in 2023 it was 4,640 billion VND, in the first 9 months of 2024 it was about 5,900 billion VND.

To get the real estate market out of its current situation, what needs to be done is to remove legal obstacles for projects in localities, creating maximum conditions for businesses to complete their products and bring them to the market. The freezing of projects with legal obstacles not only causes damage to businesses, but is a great waste for the whole society. The decrease in budget revenue in Ho Chi Minh City is due to frozen real estate, and real estate is frozen mainly due to legal obstacles.

Another thing that needs to be done is transparency in real estate ownership. Currently, the management of houses and land is not accurate, this is the key point to have a basis for taxation that needs to be completed before considering the application of tax policies. To manage the real estate sector well, it is necessary to implement digitalization programs, build a database warehouse, instead of manual operations.

A revived, stable, and transparent real estate market is what needs to be done now. Once stability and transparency are achieved, taxation is appropriate.

In general, applying a progressive tax rate to people who own many houses and lands is necessary. However, when to apply it and how to tax it appropriately are things we need to study carefully.

Production and business activities of enterprises and people are still facing difficulties. Applying taxes to people who own many houses and land may have a certain impact on the ability to recover.

LÊ THANH PHONG
RELATED NEWS

Live football match between Vietnam and Laos in the 2027 Asian Cup qualifiers

|

Live broadcast of Vietnam and Laos in the 2027 Asian Cup qualifiers, taking place at 7:00 p.m. today (November 19).

Worry about tax on tax when taxing gold bar transfer

|

According to delegate Tran Kim Yen, taxing people's savings from gold bars may not be meaningful in terms of economic management.

Stock market unexpectedly adjusted

|

Profit-taking pressure increased while buyers were cautious, causing the stock market to lose more than 10 points after an impressive recovery streak.

Heavy rain has not stopped, Song Ba Ha Hydropower Plant in Dak Lak regulates water discharge with 13,000 m3/s

|

Dak Lak - Hydropower plants are regulating water in reservoirs to ensure the safety of works during the rainy season.

Floods rise, many places in Quy Nhon are deeply flooded, traffic is paralyzed

|

Gia Lai - From this morning (November 19), prolonged heavy rain combined with floodwater from upstream has caused many areas of Quy Nhon urban area to be deeply flooded.

Hanoi talks about compensation when reclaiming prime land in Hoan Kiem Lake for a 2.14ha project

|

Hanoi - Hoan Kiem Ward is preparing a compensation, support and resettlement plan when reclaiming land to build a square and park east of Hoan Kiem Lake.

"Double-edged sword" when taxing second property

Vũ Linh - Linh Trang |

Real estate business representatives said that imposing a second real estate tax at this time could become a "double-edged sword".

"Property tax to reduce house prices is unrealistic"

Linh Trang - Vũ Linh |

Professor Dang Hung Vo - Former Deputy Minister of Natural Resources and Environment has commented on the second real estate tax proposal of the Ministry of Construction.

Second property tax: Should it be applied immediately?

Linh Trang - Vũ Linh |

Experts say that in the context of an incomplete real estate database, taxation can affect the development of the entire market.