In December last year, there was a time when Alejandro Garnacho was dropped from the Man United squad. However, he has gradually proven himself in 2025. Most recently, Garnacho contributed an assist in Man United's 2-1 win over Leicester in the fourth round of the FA Cup.
After the match, former player Roy Keane said Garnacho was only suitable as a substitute, rather than a starter. The Man United legend told Metro: “I think he plays better as a substitute, I still don’t trust him if he starts. When he comes on in the middle of the game, when the situation is tense, that’s when Garnacho really shines.”
Another Man United legend, Rio Ferdinand, disagreed with Roy Keane. He praised Garnacho and compared him to former Red Devils star Nani: "Garnacho reminds me of Nani. He can make mistakes, but he will grow. Comments saying he is unreliable will have a big impact on a boy like him. I understand Roy may think that, but at the moment Man United have no better alternative.
He is not 100% perfect, but he has the potential to improve. The important thing is that he does not lack effort and energy. He always wants the ball and will take it anywhere. Garnacho has the belief and personality that makes people want to pass the ball to him. Remember, there are many Man United players who want to stay away from the ball when they are not playing well.
Luis Nani was a great player at Man United. He played 230 games for the Red Devils, won 1 Champions League and 4 Premier League titles. Therefore, Garnacho will definitely have a long way to go to catch up with Nani.
