Supporting medical students' tuition fees is not the best way

Hoàng Văn Minh |

The Ministry of Health's proposal to provide tuition support for medical and pharmaceutical students is causing controversy.

Unlike the Pedagogy industry - which is not a priority choice and needs to waive tuition fees to attract talent - Medicine has long been an attractive field, with great appeal to candidates.

The benchmark scores of medical schools in recent years have always been among the highest, ranging from 24-29 points for General Medicine and Pharmacy. This shows that the medical industry does not lack talented candidates, regardless of whether tuition fees are exempted or not.

Every year, the number of candidates applying for admission to the medical field remains stable. This is a clear demonstration of the special attraction of this field. Therefore, exempting tuition fees is not the decisive factor for the medical field to attract more talent.

It is undeniable that the tuition fee for the medical industry is currently very high, ranging from 40-250 million/year depending on the industry, school, and program.

In fact, the tuition support policy for the medical profession has been applied before, but is limited to few majors such as pathology, forensic examination, psychiatry, infectious diseases and emergency resuscitation (according to the Law on Medical Examination and Treatment 2009 and 2023).

However, if the medical profession is also supported by the State with tuition fees like the teaching profession, and who knows, in the future many other professions will also "study" the medical profession - it will lead to inequality in vocational training, causing great pressure on the State budget.

Health care is of course important, but that does not mean that other professions in society are not important and do not need to be prioritized in terms of training.

The best solution is that the State should maintain and expand scholarship policies for students in difficult circumstances or with excellent achievements.

Currently, only the Vietnam Bank for Social Policies provides loans to orphaned students, those from poor or near-poor households, or those facing financial difficulties due to natural disasters or health problems, with a loan amount of VND4 million/month.

Meanwhile, joint stock commercial banks have not yet participated in this special market because there is no specific policy mechanism.

The proposal to support tuition fees for medical students may receive consensus from the people but is not necessarily good and optimal.

Instead of focusing on exempting tuition fees, the Ministry of Health needs to focus on improving the working environment and benefits for health workers after graduation.

One reason why health workers, especially doctors and nurses, do not want to work in public hospitals is due to high work pressure, low salary and lack of development opportunities.

Investing in healthcare infrastructure, increasing salaries and improving working conditions will help the healthcare industry attract and retain talent more effectively, not only solving immediate problems but also creating sustainable development.

Hoàng Văn Minh
TIN LIÊN QUAN

What is the current status of medical tuition fees before the proposed exemption?

|

Tuition fees for medical majors in Ho Chi Minh City at public schools range from about 41.8-84.7 million VND/year; at non-public schools from about 40-250 million VND/year.

Medical school tuition is always among the highest

|

Tuition fees for medical and pharmaceutical training are always among the highest in the industry, ranging from about 15 to nearly 200 million VND/year, depending on the school.

Proposal to support tuition and living expenses for medical students

|

The Ministry of Health proposes that medical and pharmaceutical students receive state support for tuition fees and living expenses during their time at school.

Hot major, students can get free tuition

|

The Ministry of Education and Training (MOET) has requested that universities have preferential policies, including tuition exemptions and reductions, for semiconductor students.

Non-tuition fees are a real burden for parents

|

Ho Chi Minh City plans to exempt 338 billion VND in tuition fees for students of all levels in 3 groups: public, non-public and continuing high school education.

Many households in Buon Ma Thuot are upset because of continuous water outages

|

Dak Lak - Many areas in Buon Ma Thuot city are constantly cut off from water, causing people to lack clean water for daily activities during the dry season.

The army mobilizes and appoints 12 officers of Military Region 1

|

On the afternoon of March 31, the Standing Committee of the Party Committee of Military Region 1 held a conference to hand over decisions on the transfer and appointment of cadres from agencies and units in the Military Region.

Ms. Cao Thi Hoa An holds the position of Secretary of Phu Yen Provincial Party Committee

|

Phu Yen - On the afternoon of March 31, Phu Yen Provincial Party Committee held a Conference to implement the Politburo's Decision on personnel work.

What is the current status of medical tuition fees before the proposed exemption?

Chân Phúc |

Tuition fees for medical majors in Ho Chi Minh City at public schools range from about 41.8-84.7 million VND/year; at non-public schools from about 40-250 million VND/year.

Medical school tuition is always among the highest

Vân Trang |

Tuition fees for medical and pharmaceutical training are always among the highest in the industry, ranging from about 15 to nearly 200 million VND/year, depending on the school.

Proposal to support tuition and living expenses for medical students

Thùy Linh |

The Ministry of Health proposes that medical and pharmaceutical students receive state support for tuition fees and living expenses during their time at school.

Hot major, students can get free tuition

Vân Trang |

The Ministry of Education and Training (MOET) has requested that universities have preferential policies, including tuition exemptions and reductions, for semiconductor students.

Non-tuition fees are a real burden for parents

Hoàng Văn Minh |

Ho Chi Minh City plans to exempt 338 billion VND in tuition fees for students of all levels in 3 groups: public, non-public and continuing high school education.