The MV Future is still a Vietnamese person criticized for using AI to distort many historical details

Quỳnh An |

The audience controversy over the wrong details due to the use of AI in the MV "The future is still Vietnamese".

The MV "The future is still Vietnamese" was released on the evening of August 7. The song features a collaboration between 4 voices Quoc Thien, Duong Hoang Yen, Quan A.P, Lam Bao Ngoc, with a special voice contribution from People's Artist Thu Huyen.

This is a song composed by musician Tuan cry. The MV is the work of director Tran Thanh Trung, combining traditional creativity and AI technology to create the visual part.

Director Tran Thanh Trung said that this is a music video in the national community art project VIET NAM love love love.

The MV is becoming a controversial music product about the application of AI technology in image staging.

Many opinions say that AI recreates some historical details incorrectly.

The audience commented that the image of Do Cat tunnel in Dien Bien Phu is not the same as reality; the national flag appearing on the roof was mistaken for having a yellow star flag image on a blue instead of red background; the locations marking Hoang Sa and Truong Sa displayed very blurred letters in the 0:09 second of the MV, causing the feeling of the letters being displayed incorrectly.

Hinh anh ham Do Cat do AI dung. Anh: Chup tu MV
Image of Do Cat tunnel built by AI. Photo: Taken from the MV
Hinh anh thuc te co do sao vang tung bay chien thang tren noc ham Do Cat ngay 7.5.1954. Anh: TTXVN
Actual image of the red flag with a yellow star flying victoriously on the roof of the Do Cat tunnel on May 7, 1954, Photo: VNA
Cac vi tri danh dau Hoang Sa, Truong Sa bi hien thi chu rat mo trong MV. Anh: Chup tu MV
The locations marking Hoang Sa and Truong Sa are shown with very blurred letters in the MV. Photo: Taken from the MV
Loi trong viec dung AI tao dung hinh anh co do tren mai nha (phan khoanh do). Anh: Chup tu MV
The mistake in using AI to create a red flag image on the roof (red circle). Photo: Taken from the MV

In addition, some audiences also commented that the Dong Son bronze Throne pattern - which has a thousand-year cultural value - has also been "transformed" by AI with sophisticated details carved by humans.

Hinh anh hoa tiet Trong dong Dong Son do AI tao. Anh: Chup tu MV
The pattern image of Dong Son bronze bridge is created by AI. Photo: Taken from the MV
Hoa tiet thuc te tren be mat Trong dong Dong Son. Anh: Luoc Su Toc Viet
The actual motifs on the surface of Dong Son bronze jar. Photo: Luoc Truoc Viet

Some scenes also startled the audience because they were different from the historical setting.

The scene of Tran Quoc Toan crushing an orange made by AI in 1:04 of the MV does not match the history.

Canh Tran Quoc Toan bop nat qua cam duoc AI dung. Anh: Chup tu MV
The scene of Tran Quoc Toan crushing an orange was created by AI. Photo: Taken from the MV

According to Dai Viet's throughout history, at the Binh Than Conference - where King Tran Nhan Tong convene a military conference in October 1282 to discuss the plan to defeat the Mong army, Tran Quoc Toan, who was too young, did not attend, and crushed the orange in hand.

In historical data, the Binh Than Conference took place in the plains. However, the images in the MV are created by AI to show the mountain.

The scene of the resistance war against the Japanese army during the cold war recreated by AI takes place during the day on an empty hill, contrary to historical documents, the army often marches at night under the forest canopy of the forest of Truong Son in the forest to avoid enemy aircraft.

People's Artist Thu Huyen, although singing in the MV, did not appear directly, but was replaced with AI-generated images.

A part of the audience expressed disagreement with this approach, saying that the crew could use many valuable and authentic documents about the military-civilian relationship in history instead of relying too much on AI.

Quỳnh An
RELATED NEWS

Phuong My Chi, Hoa Minzy, HIEUTHUHAI land a series of weekend concerts in Hanoi

|

This weekend, music events will take place in Hanoi with the participation of stars, including Phuong My Chi, Hoa Minzy, HIEUTHUHAI...

Singer makes Phuong My Chi cry 3 times

|

Phuong My Chi feels happy and proud of this special sister in "Em xinh say hi".

7 million-view MVs of Hong Loan - adopted daughter of Vu Linh

|

Hong Loan - the daughter of the late artist Vu Linh posted many MVs and clips on her personal YouTube channel, attracting a large number of views, including 7 outstanding songs.

National Assembly Chairman: Vietnam always identifies Japan as a leading strategic partner

|

The National Assembly Chairman stated that Vietnam always identifies Japan as a leading strategic partner, especially in the fields of economy, investment and technology transfer.

Reasons why Nguyen Canh Di Street, Hanoi has been muddy for many years but has not been repaired

|

A representative of Hanoi Housing and Urban Development Trading Joint Stock Company explained the reason why Nguyen Canh Di Street has been degraded for many years but has not been repaired or upgraded.

Chairman of Can Tho Requested Review of All Products at Dermatology Hospital

|

Can Tho - The Chairman of the City People's Committee requested to inspect and review all products traded at Can Tho City Dermatology Hospital.

Vietnam Bank Trade Union organizes the 5th Executive Committee meeting

|

The Vietnam Bank Trade Union held the 5th Executive Committee meeting for the 2023-2028 term.

Forecast of the impact of tropical depression and dangerous areas in the next 24 hours

|

According to the meteorological agency, the area affected by the tropical depression is the northeastern sea of the East Sea, warning of level 3 natural disaster risk.

Phuong My Chi, Hoa Minzy, HIEUTHUHAI land a series of weekend concerts in Hanoi

Quỳnh An |

This weekend, music events will take place in Hanoi with the participation of stars, including Phuong My Chi, Hoa Minzy, HIEUTHUHAI...

Singer makes Phuong My Chi cry 3 times

Quỳnh An |

Phuong My Chi feels happy and proud of this special sister in "Em xinh say hi".

7 million-view MVs of Hong Loan - adopted daughter of Vu Linh

Quỳnh An |

Hong Loan - the daughter of the late artist Vu Linh posted many MVs and clips on her personal YouTube channel, attracting a large number of views, including 7 outstanding songs.