Car parking fee collection loses VND 2.28 billion, needs solutions to prevent revenue loss

MINH QUÂN |

After 4 years of collecting parking fees on 20 routes, Ho Chi Minh City not only has not made a profit but has also reported a loss of more than 2.28 billion VND.

occupiing car parking positions to keep motorbikes

On the afternoon of March 29, some spontaneous motorbike parking lots on Phan Chu Trinh Street (District 1) occupied car parking lots to build parking lots, collecting 20,000 VND/unit. Motorbikes are messy from the sidewalk to the road, causing disorder and affecting traffic.

Vi tri do oto thu phi tren duong Phan Chu Trinh bi chiem dung de giu xe may. Anh: Minh Quan
The location of the toll collection car parking on Phan Chu Trinh Street was occupied to keep motorbikes. Photo: Minh Quan

On An Duong Vuong Street (District 5), the situation of occupying car parking locations also occurs. auto parts shops here have turned the roadway into a car repair area.

Shops staff set chairs on the street to greet customers, even chasing cars that needed parking with the reason of " avoiding business frontage".

Nhieu vi tri do oto thu phi tren duong An Duong Vuong bi cac cua hang kinh doanh phu tung oto chiem dung. Anh: Minh Quan
Seats to book parking tickets for cars collecting tolls on An Duong Vuong Street (District 5). Photo: Minh Quan

According to the Youth Volunteer Public Service Company Limited, on many toll routes such as An Duong Vuong (District 5), Thu Khoa Huan, Phan Chu Trinh, Ngo Duc Ke (District 1), etc., the situation of occupying parking spaces, obstructing vehicles from entering the parking lot, illegally collecting fees and preventing staff from booking through software is still common.

In addition, many drivers avoid paying the fee by registering to park for an hour but actually park for longer without paying according to regulations.

Statistics show that in 2021, there was a peak month when more than 18,000 vehicles violated the fee payment. Although compliance awareness has improved recently, there are still 4,000 - 5,000 violations per month.

According to the Ho Chi Minh City Department of Transport, from December 2020 to the end of October 2024, Ho Chi Minh City will implement the collection of hourly parking fees for cars on 20 routes, earning 22.04 billion VND, but operating costs will reach 24.32 billion VND, leading to a loss of 2.28 billion VND.

Applying anti- Harm technology

The Ho Chi Minh City Department of Transport said that the coordination and handling of violations between the toll collection unit and the functional forces under the District People's Committee, the police force has not yet thoroughly handled many violations.

Meanwhile, MyParking software - currently used for fee collection - still has many errors in the payment process, causing inconvenience to users.

Diem do oto thu phi tren duong Le Lai (Quan 1) kin xe. Anh: Minh Quan
The toll parking lot on Le Lai Street (District 1) is full. Photo: Minh Quan

From January 1, 2025, Youth Volunteer Public Service Company Limited has piloted fee collection using RFID technology on three routes: Hai Ba Trung, Le Lai and Pham Huu Chi.

This system will automatically deduct fees through the traffic account using the eTag/e Pass reader device posted on the vehicle or creating a dynamic QR code for the driver to scan and pay.

This method helps limit direct contact, avoid controversy and negativity, while reducing the time for downloading the application and payment. If the pilot is successful, the model will be replicated on many other routes.

According to Dr. Tran Quang Thang - Director of the Ho Chi Minh City Institute of Economics and Management, despite applying new technology, combating loss of car parking fees will be difficult to achieve effectively without coordination between authorities.

Local authorities and police forces need to take strong action against individuals who arbitrarily collect fees and occupy parking spaces. At the same time, there should be strict sanctions against drivers who intentionally violate the law to avoid creating a bad precedent.

On the other hand, propaganda work also needs to be promoted, helping people and drivers understand the regulations and raise awareness of compliance. "When the toll collection system operates effectively, it will not only help the city increase revenue but also contribute to restoring urban order and reducing traffic congestion," said Mr. Thang.

MINH QUÂN
TIN LIÊN QUAN

Surprised by the situation of collecting fees for parking cars on Ho Chi Minh City streets

|

HCMC - Some roads are closed to cars, while many other routes are occupied by people for business or motorbike parking, affecting toll collection activities.

I thought it was unlikely why collecting car parking fees cost 2.28 billion VND

|

The road is available, only collecting parking fees for cars, but after 4 years of operation, the unit has lost 2.28 billion VND.

HCMC loses VND2.28 billion after 4 years of collecting car parking fees on the road

|

HCMC - Hours apart parking fees on 20 routes from December 2020 to the end of October 2024 were collected for VND 22.04 billion, but VND 24.32 billion was spent, accounting for a loss of VND 2.28 billion.

Forecast of changes in La Nina and weather in the summer of 2025

|

The impact of La Nina is forecast to affect the weather in the summer of 2025.

Fierce tanker truck on fire on Noi Bai - Lao Cai Expressway

|

A tanker truck caught fire fiercely on the Noi Bai - Lao Cai Expressway this morning (January 1).

After April 10, unreported projects will be considered untroubled

|

After April 10, the national public investment system will not receive further information about investment projects with difficulties, long backlogs and is considered no longer stuck.

Gold prices increase sharply, Germanyans worry about gold reserves in the US

|

In the context of the continuous increase in gold prices, Germans are starting to worry about more than 110 billion euros in gold reserves in the US.

Apartment residents in Ho Chi Minh City check houses after earthquake in Myanmar

|

HCMC - After the earthquake in Myanmar, many HCMC residents are worried, proactively checking their homes and assessing their safety level.

Surprised by the situation of collecting fees for parking cars on Ho Chi Minh City streets

MINH QUÂN |

HCMC - Some roads are closed to cars, while many other routes are occupied by people for business or motorbike parking, affecting toll collection activities.

I thought it was unlikely why collecting car parking fees cost 2.28 billion VND

Lê Thanh Phong |

The road is available, only collecting parking fees for cars, but after 4 years of operation, the unit has lost 2.28 billion VND.

HCMC loses VND2.28 billion after 4 years of collecting car parking fees on the road

MINH QUÂN |

HCMC - Hours apart parking fees on 20 routes from December 2020 to the end of October 2024 were collected for VND 22.04 billion, but VND 24.32 billion was spent, accounting for a loss of VND 2.28 billion.