Ideas for new punishments

LÊ VINH |

The Brazilian Supreme Sports Court has just issued an unprecedented ruling, forcing defender Victor Gabriel (Internacional) to be sidelined until the victim Gabriel Pec (Cruzeiro) fully recovers, or up to 6 months, after a tackle that broke his opponent's tibia.

Meaning, not stopping at the fixed number of penalty matches, this sentence forces the player who caused the consequences to "accompany" the recovery period of his colleague. The question is, is this a suggestion for football federations around the world to study this penalty model for serious fouls?

For many years, the penalty frame for tackles has remained limited: a few matches of suspension, a few weeks of banned play with fines. But for victims, the price to pay is sometimes months of treatment, training recovery, affecting performance and even their career. The mismatch between the short "conviction" time of the offender and the long days of pain of the victim certainly creates a feeling of injustice on the pitch.

Attaching the suspension period to the injury recovery process of the victim has great deterrent meaning. When the price of an impulsive moment or a rough tackle is a career gap equivalent to the victim, each player will have to be more careful in each foot swing decision. From there, the awareness of protecting legs of colleagues will have a basis to improve.

Of course, to institutionalize such a penalty is not simple, because it requires absolute transparency from the health sector to avoid the risk of abuse or prolonging virtual recovery time, as well as many other related issues.

However, researching such a compatible penalty mechanism may also be necessary. Football cannot only protect the match with time-sensitive red cards, but needs sanctions that are strong enough to protect the player's professional life. Looking at the decision of the Brazilian Court is not to mechanically imitate, but to find a more appropriate and fair balance of justice for those involved.

LÊ VINH
RELATED NEWS

CAS upholds penalty for 7 naturalized Malaysian players

|

The Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) has issued a final ruling related to the case of 7 illegal naturalized players of Malaysian football.

Dinh Bac receives penalty from AFC

|

AFC issued a penalty to VFF and striker Nguyen Dinh Bac after violations at SEA Games 33 and the 2026 AFC U23 Championship.

Malaysian football faces additional penalty from AFC

|

Malaysian football is at risk of receiving another penalty from the AFC after a fan disruption in the AFC Champions League Two match.

Submit to the National Assembly specific policies to accelerate projects serving APEC 2027

|

The Government submits to the National Assembly for consideration 5 specific policy groups to accelerate projects serving APEC 2027 in Phu Quoc.

Government approves dossier of project to establish wards under Bac Ninh province

|

The Government decided to approve the dossier of the Project on establishing wards under Bac Ninh province at the request of the Ministry of Home Affairs.

National Assembly discusses expanding the scope of state compensation

|

On the morning of August 3, the National Assembly listened to the submission and appraisal report on the Law amending and supplementing a number of articles of the Law on State Compensation Liability.

Proposal for high school graduation exam on computer, students hope for a clear roadmap soon

|

The Ministry of Education and Training has just submitted to the Prime Minister a project to organize the high school graduation exam on computers. Many students support it but hope for a clear roadmap to ensure fairness.

CAS upholds penalty for 7 naturalized Malaysian players

Thanh Vũ |

The Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) has issued a final ruling related to the case of 7 illegal naturalized players of Malaysian football.

Dinh Bac receives penalty from AFC

MINH PHONG |

AFC issued a penalty to VFF and striker Nguyen Dinh Bac after violations at SEA Games 33 and the 2026 AFC U23 Championship.

Malaysian football faces additional penalty from AFC

MINH PHONG |

Malaysian football is at risk of receiving another penalty from the AFC after a fan disruption in the AFC Champions League Two match.